12 Best Jelly Roll Pans Reviewed For Your Baking Needs

It’s easy to confuse a jelly roll pan with your regular half-sheet baking pan. They are about precisely the same size -15 by 10 inches versus 18 by 13 inches-, and many come in an inch tall border that is straight-sided for ease when making small batches of biscuits or roasted veggies. The best part? You can fit two side by side on most oven racks.

You should look for a jelly roll pan with a rim around its edge. This will allow you to grip it easier when taking out and transporting it in your oven, as well as stabilize any warping that may occur due to the greater temperature ranges found within them.

The best jelly roll pans are easy to use and make baking much easier. They come in a variety of sizes, from small to extra large. This article provides an overview of the top twelve jelly roll pans on the market today, including their pros and cons so you can find the perfect one for your needs.

silicone jelly roll pan

What is a Jelly Roll Pan?

A jelly roll pan is a baking sheet with vertical sides that are about one inch tall. Its name actually comes from its old-time use as a pan that was used to make jelly rolls, which were cakes that were filled with fruit preserves or other sweet fillings and rolled up for easy serving. The pans have found new life in the modern-day kitchen as an excellent pan for baking cookies and pastries.

The best thing about them is how versatile they are, particularly because of their size. You can fit two standard jelly roll pans side by side on most oven racks, giving you the ability to bake multiple different desserts at once if you need to prepare food for a big gathering or party. It’s also great for those with limited counter space who want to save on effort and time by baking smaller batches of treats.

The History of Jelly Roll Pans

Jelly roll pans have changed little since their inception over 200 years ago when they first came into use as cake pans in the early 1800s. They gained their name from a type of cake that was originally made with a jelly filling that was rolled up and cut into slices for serving.

The term is now more commonly used to describe any type of sheet pan that has sides around one inch tall, which makes it perfect for small-batch desserts or roasting veggies. In fact, most people know them simply as ‘sheet’ pans.

The History of Jelly Roll Pans

List of 12 Best Jelly Roll Pans Reviews

1. Chicago Metallic Commercial II Traditional Uncoated True Jelly Roll Pan

Chicago Metallic Commercial II Traditional Uncoated True Jelly Roll Pan is a metal pan designed to withstand high heat. It features a traditional, uncoated surface that is ideal for baking one-sheet dinners, jelly rolls, bars, and cookies. This 14.75-inch by 9.75-inch by 1-Inch pan has wire-reinforced rims so the sheet won’t warp over time from being placed in the oven at too high of a temperature or from heating up too fast when not preheated properly before going into the oven as directed in the manual included with every purchase. We recommend washing your pans after use with a dishwasher or hand washing them with warm water and soap if you want to extend their life span even longer.

Chicago Metallic Commercial II Traditional Uncoated True Jelly Roll Pan, 15-Inch by10-Inch

$16.22
2 new from $15.99
2 used from $12.81
Free shipping
as of April 19, 2024 1:36 pm

Features

  • SWEET AND SAVORY BAKING: versatile cookie sheet is perfect for making jelly rolls, cookies, pastries, pizza, one-pan meals, roasted vegetables, and more
  • GREAT RESULTS: traditional, uncoated pan evenly distributes heat for consistent baking
  • DURABLE: heavy-weight aluminized steel stands up to frequent use; oven-safe to 450°F / 232°C
  • SPECIALLY DESIGNED: features wire-rod reinforced rims to prevent warping
  • STANDARD SIZE: interior measures 14.75" L x 9.75​​" W x 1" H

2. USA Pan Bakeware Jelly Roll Pan

The Classic Jelly Roll Sheet Pan is the perfect baking and roasting accessory for any home baker. This commercial-grade, heavy-gauge aluminized steel pan will make your recipes come out beautifully every time with its lifetime warranty. Baking pans are designed to allow air circulation, which helps reduce the amount of time it takes for your baked goods and makes them come out more even.

Nonstick American is the perfect choice for the easy release of baked goods and easy cleaning. Its PTFE, PFOA & BPA-free silicone coating ensures your food won’t stick to the pan while releasing it at 350°F in ovens or over stovetop burners with no need for oiling. Great for convection cooking too so cleanup takes just 3 steps: wash hot water mild soap gentle sponge.

USA Pan Bakeware Jelly Roll Pan, Warp Resistant Nonstick Baking Pan, Made in the USA from Aluminized Steel

$24.95
$18.74
16 new from $18.73
2 used from $16.64
Free shipping
as of April 19, 2024 1:36 pm

Features

  • Classic jelly roll sheet pan for baking and roasting cookies, vegetables, and cakes; commercial grade and heavy gauge aluminized steel
  • Baking pans feature unique design with corrugated surface; facilitates air circulation for a quick release and evenly baked baked-goods
  • Nonstick America coat coating - a patented silicone coating which is PTFE, PFOA and BPA free - provides easy release of baked-goods and easy clean up; wash with hot water, mild soap and gentle sponge
  • Baking surface Dimensions: 14. 25 x 9. 375 x 1 inches outer dimensions: 14. 75 x 9. 875 x 1 inches
  • USA Pan is a Bundy family company which has proudly manufactured high quality bakeware and provided jobs in the USA for over 50 years

3. Wilton Performance Pans Aluminum Jelly Roll and Cookie Pan

There are many shapes for all your baking needs these days including jelly roll pans. This Wilton Performance Pans aluminum jelly roll and cookie pan is the most versatile of them all. The heavy gauge 3/4″ metal provides uniform heating so they can be used to make everything from brownies, bars, or layered cakes that turn into an easy no-bake dessert just waiting to have its filling added. It’s also great for boiling eggs, making soup, or even steaming vegetables. Top this with our easy way to whip egg whites quickly without the doubt of them becoming too stiff.

Wilton Performance Baking Pans Aluminum Jelly Roll Pan, 10.5 x 15.5-Inch

$18.11
$16.47
16 new from $16.47
Free shipping
as of April 19, 2024 1:36 pm

Features

  • Versatile Baking Supply: A must-have addition to your kitchen, our sheet pan for baking is perfect for both seasoned bakers and cooking enthusiasts, elevating your baking game to new heights.
  • Baking Essential: This multi-purpose jelly roll pan is designed to handle various recipes, from classic jelly rolls to delectable cookies, savory roasted vegetables, sheet cakes and even pizza.
  • Sturdy and Warp-Resistant: The durable aluminum build of our baking sheet pan guarantees long-lasting performance without warping, making it a reliable kitchen companion.
  • Easy to Clean: With its smooth surface, our cookie pan is effortless to clean, and it withstands repeated use, offering hassle-free maintenance for your busy kitchen.
  • Ideal Size for Everyday Baking: Our 10.5 x 15.5-in. baking pan is the perfect size for daily baking needs, whether you're a seasoned baker or a beginner, bringing joy and delicious treats to your home.

4. Warp-Resistant Nonstick Jelly Roll Pan

The diamond-textured surface of the jelly roll pan produces perfect cookies and other baked goods. It measures 14.8 x 10 inches exteriorly with an interior dimension to fit even large items like bread dough or scones that measure 9 1/2″ tall by 1 inch thick at their largest point (not including handles). This means your next batch will be sure not only to look great but taste as good too.

Have you ever tried to release cookies from a jelly roll sheet after they’ve been baked? It’s impossible. Your hands are covered in dough and there is NOTHING between your fingers but hot, sticky cookie sheets. That will no longer happen with this nonstick 10×15 pan because it is easy. Release surface that makes sliding off of these pans as simple as can be, almost too easy if we’re being honest here.

The Swiss roll pan is a professional’s best friend. It has durable, food-safe steel that will last for years to come. The rolled edges mean there are no worries of rusting or chrome flaking off into your meal. This type of cookie sheet offers superior quality with its design in mind. And not only does it hold up beautifully but also maintains even heating during the cooking process so you can achieve perfect results every time.

Ultra Cuisine’s jelly roll sheet pans clean up in a snap with their high-quality PFOA and PTFE-free coating. It protects against scratches, abrasions, stainings corrosion so you can put them right into the dishwasher or hand wash it without scrubbing. You will have no problem using these as they’re not too big to handle but just small enough that any messes won’t be an issue either way because there is nothing worse than cleaning dirty dishes from one pan and trying unsuccessfully at another before realizing what might’ve been done if those had worked after all.

Nonstick Jelly Roll Baking Sheet Pan by Ultra Cuisine – Food-Safe, Warp & Scratch Resistant Texture for Airflow, & Carbon Steel Design Durable for Professional Quality Roasting, Size 10 x 15 inch

$21.99
2 new from $21.99
1 used from $19.49
Free shipping
as of April 19, 2024 1:36 pm

Features

  • ACHIEVE FLAWLESS BAKING RESULTS: The 10x15 jelly roll pan ensures even airflow distribution for perfectly baked cookies and proteins every time, thanks to its diamond textured surface. The exterior measures 14.8 x 10.0 x 1.1 inches and the interior 14.01 x 9.1 x 1.1 inches. This 10 inch pan guarantees superior baked goodies every time
  • EFFORTLESS COOKIE RELEASE: This nonstick baking sheet pan facilitates easy cookie release without requiring any spraying. Say goodbye to imperfect cookies sticking to your jelly roll cookie sheet. Your cookies will effortlessly slide off this 10 inch nonstick pan. It’s coated with a food-safe, PFOA-free, and PTFE-free coating for quick and easy cookie release
  • ROBUST CARBON STEEL DESIGN: The baking pan is made of food-safe, durable, warp-resistant, scratch-resistant carbon steel. Its rolled edges make it a professional-grade Swiss roll pan. There's no risk of rust or chrome flaking off into your food. The Ultra Cuisine jelly roll sheet offers oven-safe, long-lasting superior quality
  • EASY CLEANING: The Ultra Cuisine's jelly roll sheet pan is designed for easy clean-up. Its high-quality PFOA-free, PTFE-free coating protects against scratches, abrasions, staining, and corrosion. Hand wash this nonstick baking sheet effortlessly without scrubbing or scouring. For best results, use parchment paper sheets or silicone baking mats
  • PROUDLY DESIGNED IN THE USA: Experience professional baking with Ultra Cuisine's nonstick baking sheet. Each cookie sheet comes with a complimentary recipe ebook. Bake like a pro for a lifetime with our jelly roll cookie sheet, proudly designed in Colorado, USA

5. Nordic Ware Jelly Roll Pan

The Nordic Ware Jelly Roll Pans are the last pans you will ever buy. The embossed grid pattern and Prism grid make it easier to slide food in and out of the oven for a delicious, perfectly browned result every time – without warping like lesser-quality pans.

Dishwasher-safe aluminum reduces hot spots caused by melting butter or overheating metal which could cause baked goods to burn on the top before they’re cooked all the way through. Get perfect results with less time and effort using these durable kitchen essentials.

Nordic Ware Prism Baking, 1 Pack, Natural

$20.70
4 new from $20.70
Free shipping
as of April 19, 2024 1:36 pm

Features

  • Embossed grid pattern enhances the look and performance of our hugely popular baking pans
  • Prism grid adds durability and provides easy release while also improving air flow for uniform crisping
  • Natural aluminum affords the best possible heat dispersion to create perfectly browned baked goods every time and the reinforced encapsulated steel rim prevents warping
  • Hand wash only
  • Made in USA

6. Calphalon Classic Bakeware Nonstick Jelly Roll Pan

The Calphalon Classic Bakeware Nonstick Jelly Roll Pan has a 13-gauge thickness with 2 layers of nonstick coating that are perfect for baking your favorite treats. The Heavy gauge aluminum construction promotes even heating, is durable, and does not warp in the oven. The heavy-duty exterior means food won’t stick to the pan while cooking or when transferring from a hot surface without adding oil. 

High-grade steel assures even browning over the entire surface and won’t react to acidic foods like tomatoes and wine sauces. This dishwasher-safe 12 by 17-inch jelly roll pan will last a lifetime without peeling or bubbling.

Calphalon Classic Bakeware 12-by-17-Inch Rectangular Nonstick Jelly Roll Pan

as of April 19, 2024 1:36 pm

Features

  • Nonstick jelly roll pan made of heavy-gauge, aluminized steel
  • Heavy-duty construction means no twisting or warping
  • Two-tone surface promotes perfect browning
  • Oven safe to 450 degrees F; not broiler safe; not dishwasher safe
  • Measures 12 by 17 inches; lifetime warranty

7. Chicago Metallic Professional Non-Stick Cookie/Jelly-Roll Pan Set with Cooling Rack

These non-stick baking sheets are perfect for cooking and baking. You’ll have the flexibility to make jelly rolls, bars of cookies, or any other type of food that needs one large sheet pan. This set includes four pieces which makes it great value too. With its heavy-weight carbon steel baking sheet, you can be sure that the food will cook evenly and thoroughly. It’s also suitable for all oven types – no need to worry about an inconsistent result. The Chicago Metallic Baking Sheets and Cooling Rack are a must-have for any kitchen.

Not only do they provide easy cleanup, but their nonstick surface ensures that your baked goods come out without the need for added oil or butter which not only saves you time in cooking but reduces calories as well. The non-stick baking sheet is a great space saver in the cupboard, drawer, or countertop rack. They can be stacked within other baking sheets and will not scratch against each other like metal pans do when they’re placed on top of one another. This makes it easier to find your favorite. The Baking Sheets are so clean you can put them in the dishwasher to make cleanup go faster. But please hand wash these babies for optimal product life.

Chicago Metallic Professional Non-Stick Cookie/Jelly-Roll Pan Set with Cooling Rack, 17-Inch-by-12.25-Inch

$37.99
$24.15
8 used from $14.65
Free shipping
as of April 19, 2024 1:36 pm

Features

  • IDEAL FOR BAKING MULTIPLE DISHES: The Chicago Metallic Non-Stick Baking Sheet Set is ideal for all types of baking and cooking. Have the flexibility to bake jelly rolls, bars, cookies, one-sheet pan meals, roast vegetables or reheat leftovers
  • CONSISTENT HEAT DISTRIBUTION: The baking sheet is made from heavy-weight carbon steel to evenly disperse weight and heat for consistent baking results. Suitable for all oven types
  • NON-STICK COATING FOR EASY RELEASE: The Chicago Metallic Baking Sheets and Cooling Rack feature a non-stick surface. The non-stick coating calls for an exceptional baked good release and easy clean up
  • THE PERFECT SIZED BAKING SHEET SET: The sheets feature a wire rod reinforced rim to prevent any warping. The 2 baking sheet pans measure 17.75" x 13" x 1"; inner dimensions are 17" x 12.25"x 1". The cooling rack measures 16.75" x 11.5"
  • SPACE SAVING STORAGE: This non-stick baking sheet is easy to store and can be stacked within other baking sheets, making it a great space saver in the cupboard, drawer, or countertop rack

8. AmazonCommercial Aluminum Baking Sheet Pan, Jelly Roll Pan

A kitchen standard, the commercial aluminum baking sheet pan is an excellent choice for bakers of any skill level. The lightweight but sturdy dish has a non-stick surface that makes cleaning up quick and easy with little to no scrubbing required.

Use the heavy-gauge rolled steel edge on this item to ensure uniform browning on whatever you’ve made. With proper care, the bakeware will last for years of high production time in your restaurant or bakery business. Hand washes before first use and after each use with warm water and soap only.

AmazonCommercial Aluminum Baking Sheet Pan, Jelly Roll Sheet, 15.1 x 10.6 Inch, Pack of 2

as of April 19, 2024 1:36 pm

Features

  • Even heating: the pan’s aluminum construction offers excellent heat conductivity, which helps food bake and brown evenly
  • Rustproof: resists rust for longer-lasting quality and performance
  • Warp resistant: reinforced encapsulated steel rim provides added durability and prevents warping
  • Easy care: hand-wash only with warm, soapy water before first time use and after each use
  • Warranty: backed by an AmazonCommercial 1-year limited warranty

9. Ultra Cuisine Jelly Roll Pan

Get the best baking results with these Commercial-Grade, Warpingresistant aluminum sheet pans. Ultra Cuisine’s commercial-grade sheets are designed for superior browning and protection against warp. They come in two sizes: 16″x11″ jelly-roll shape or 15 3/4 x 10 1/2 inch rectangular (set of 2). No more warping, greasy messes. With the benefit of a 1.3-inch high steel reinforced rim on our baking sheets. You’ll never have to worry about your food being stuck or burned again because it won’t be able to spill its contents when cooking at home with us. In addition, this durability helps keep foods from sticking together while they’re in storage too – which saves time and money every month.

The high-grade aluminum of this cookie sheet pan is safe for food, nontoxic, and dishwasher-friendly. Designed to be used in the oven or on stovetop cooking; it can also double as a roasting pan. The perfect set that’ll suit any household need with its diverse uses – get yours today if you’re looking forward to mastering new recipes yourself soon enough too.

Never worry about the durability of your aluminum baking pans again. This high-quality, top-grade material is designed to withstand even hot temperatures without rusting. You can serve up all sorts of delicious treats with these babies in no time thanks to their premium quality construction and ability to remain neglected by busy kitchens everywhere.

Jelly Roll Baking Sheet Pans - Professional Aluminum Cookie Sheet Set of 2 - Durable, Oven-Safe, Non-Toxic, Easy Clean, Commercial Quality - 16x11-inch - Rimmed Baking Sheets for Baking and Roasting

$33.00
$29.99
as of April 19, 2024 1:36 pm

Features

  • BAKE LIKE A PRO FOR A LIFETIME: Bake evenly with commercial-grade, warp-resistant aluminum baking sheet pans. Ultra Cuisine’s aluminum baking pans are designed with premium aluminum for superior baking and a specialized reinforced steel rim to prevent warping. The jelly roll pans measure exterior 16.1 x 11.2 x 1.3-inches and interior 15.3 x 10.3 x 1.3-inches - set of 2 jelly roll sheet pans
  • EASY TO CLEAN: Save time, easy clean up! Unlike half sheet pans from other brands, Ultra Cuisine’s baking sheet pans are designed with a 1.3 inch high steel reinforced rim that prevents the baking pan from warping and grease from spilling. Hand wash is recommended but if the product ends up in the dishwasher and discoloration occurs, this is only cosmetic and the baking properties and safety of the product are not impacted.
  • HIGH-QUALITY ALUMINUM BAKING SHEET: Food-safe, family choice; designed with high-grade aluminum, Ultra Cuisine’s cookie sheet pans are food-safe, non-toxic, oven-safe, and durable; the perfect baking set for the family; use as a cookie sheet for cookies, roasting pan for roasted chicken, or jelly roll pan for Swiss rolls
  • BUILT TO LAST: Designed to never rust! Ultra Cuisine sourced top grade aluminum in the making of these premium aluminum baking pans, ensuring they can withstand hot temperatures without rusting. Rest assured, our baking sheet pans are ready to take on all of your kitchen requirements.
  • PROUDLY DESIGNED IN COLORADO, USA: Ultra Cuisine's jelly roll sheet pans are designed in Colorado, USA and come with a free recipe ebook with over 100 delicious recipes for a lifetime of happy baking with Ultra Cuisine's jelly roll baking sheet aluminum pan set

10. Nordic Ware Jelly Roll Naturals Aluminum Nonstick Pan

This Nordic Ware pan may be small, but this little guy packs a big punch. The superior heat conductivity of aluminum makes baking simple and delicious. The gold nonstick interior is scratch-resistant and easy to release and clean up. The reinforced rim securely locks the pan in place to prevent warping during use. This aluminum jelly roll natural pan will work well for any baked good occasion, whether you’re entertaining guests or making homemade cinnamon rolls for that family brunch on Sunday morning.

Nordic Ware Jelly Roll Naturals Aluminum Nonstick, 15.125 x 10.625

$26.00
$21.85
5 new from $21.85
1 used from $13.46
Free shipping
as of April 19, 2024 1:36 pm

Features

  • Natural aluminium: Built to stand the test of time, this baking sheet pan is designed to produce evenly baked goods every time for many years to come
  • Easy cleaning: Made with PFOA-free non-stick coating, the jelly roll sheet pan releases food effortlessly and clean-up is a complete breeze by hand
  • Prevents warping: This premium baking pan features a reinforced encapsulated steel rim to keep it in excellent shape. Fits into European sized ovens
  • Long warranty: We take pride in presenting the very finest products. We are confident in the quality of our non-stick baking sheet, and so we supply it with a 5-year warranty
  • American made: All Nordic Ware baking accessories are proudly made in the USA to exacting standards, with careful attention to detail in the manufacturing process

11. All-Clad Pro-Release Nonstick Bakeware Jelly Roll Pan

This Jelly Roll Pan is perfect for making large batches of baked goods and more. The 10″ x 15 “surface area enables you to cook food evenly, so your treats come out perfectly every time. Made from commercial-grade aluminized steel that is warp-resistant (oven safe to 450°F). Perfect for any professional-looking kitchen or restaurant.

Made to be as durable and easy to care for as possible, this pan is coated with a food-safe PFOA-free material. The ceramic-reinforced nonstick exterior will resist scratches while still releasing your favorite foods from one batch of cooking right into another.

The size and shape of these handles make them perfect for a secure grip. They can be used to safely lift heavy items without worrying about dropping them, while also being gentle on your hands when washing up in the sink or dishwasher. Use plastic utensils so they don’t break down over time – but if you want something more durable there’s a silicone option available too.

All-Clad Pro-Release Nonstick Bakeware Jelly Roll Pan, 12 x 15 inch, Gray

$46.98
5 new from $46.98
Free shipping
as of April 19, 2024 1:36 pm

Features

  • Experience the perfection of baking with the All-Clad Pro-Release Nonstick Bakeware Jelly Roll Pan, 10 x 15 inches. Crafted for precision, this pan guarantees even baking and easy release
  • Warp resistant, heavy gauge aluminized steel conducts heat uniformly for perfectly even baking. The durable, ceramic-reinforced coating resists scratches and staining, and provides an easy release, batch after batch
  • Design You Will Love- Handles are generously sized, allowing for plenty of room to grip with oven mitts without touching delicate batters. The rounded corners and lighter colored nonstick which help prevent overbrowning
  • Easy Care- Oven safe up to 450°F. Dishwasher Safe. To preserve the nonstick quality over time, we recommend using silicone, nylon or wooden utensils and washing your bakeware with a soap and sponge. Limited Lifetime Warranty
  • Designed in Canonsburg, PA - USA, Made in China

12. 360 Stainless Steel Jelly Roll Pan

360 Bakeware’s Surgical Grade stainless steel, multi-core design for rapid and even heat distribution. These pans are 40% thicker than most brands on the market! It has a healthier eco-friendly coating that makes them safe to use in your oven or microwave as well. The multi-purpose pan is the perfect gadget for any kitchen. With its durable, nonstick exterior and ergonomic handles that are easier to use than traditional pans, this item will quickly become one of your favorite gadgets.

West Bend, Wisconsin is home to one of the world’s leading bakeware manufacturers. Recognized by the EPA for its manufacturing process which does not use harsh chemicals but instead employs a dry sanding technique in order to produce better results and easier clean-up; 360 Bakeware makes it easy on cooks everywhere.

360 Stainless Steel Jelly Roll Pan (14"x10"), Handcrafted in the USA, 5 Ply, Stainless Steel Bakeware, Baking Pan, Roasting Pan

$159.00
as of April 19, 2024 1:36 pm

Features

  • Quality and Construction: Surgical Grade Stainless Steel. Multi Core for rapid and even heat distribution. 360 Bakeware is thicker than most bakeware brands on the market: .070” thick. Our Surgical Grade Stainless Steel Cooking surface gives you a healthy alternative coated nonstick frying pans or any aluminum pots and pans set.
  • Details to Make Your Life Easier: Oven safe up to 500 degrees F. Ergonomic handles for easier and better control. Multi Core for even heat distribution.
  • 360 Bakeware is manufactured in West Bend, Wisconsin. Recognized by the EPA; our manufacturing process includes no harsh chemicals but instead uses a dry sanding process to produce a smoother finish, which results in easier clean-up and a nicer final product.
  • Proudly Handcrafted in the United States

Tips and guide to buying the best Jelly Roll Pan

When shopping for a new jelly roll pan, it is important to take into consideration the material and size of your oven. There are two main choices: aluminum or steel with an aluminized coating on it which makes them more durable than their counterparts made from pure metal like iron or carbon steel (which rusts). Below we’ll go over some other features that can help you find just what you need to read ahead:

Material

Aluminum is the most common choice, as it distributes heat quickly and evenly. It has a tendency to warp at higher temperatures than steel does, so avoid buying jelly roll pans with edges that are more than an inch tall if you plan on baking anything near the 400° mark.

Steel with an aluminized coating on it works well for many different types of ovens due to its lack of warping at high temperatures. These pans are typically lightweight, which can make them easier to handle when removing or transporting them in your oven, but be aware that they will rust over time if not properly taken care of. Also, be sure to dry them fully after hand washing since water spots can cause rusting faster.

Size

Most jelly roll pans are one foot long, but if you have a small oven that can’t accommodate two next to each other then choose a smaller option. It should only be about 10 inches wide at most and around eight inches deep. If you need a deeper pan for roasting veggies or making your Sunday gravy, then go with a standard-sized sheet pan since the extra depth is not really necessary for baking desserts.

Durability and Care

As mentioned, aluminum pans can warp at high oven temperatures and steel with an aluminized coating on it has a tendency to rust over time. If you’re looking for durability then go with pure stainless steel or cast iron instead; they don’t warp and are very easy to take care of (just make sure not to use any soap when hand washing to avoid damaging the surface). Why Jelly Roll Pans Aren’t Perfect

The biggest drawback of using jelly roll pans is that cleaning them isn’t as easy as other types of baking sheets. They require more effort than just wiping down and there is a chance that some baked-on food particles will stick around even after you attempt scrubbing them off. You can try using baking soda or an abrasive cleaner, but you’ll want to avoid steel wool at all costs.

It will scratch the surface and cause rusting to take place faster. Also, be aware that jelly roll pans are not typically oven-safe above 500°. If you want to broil something at high temperatures then opt for a sheet pan with higher sides than just an inch tall so that heat can’t get trapped inside and warp your pan.

Tips for using your Jelly Roll Pan

  • As stated above, aluminum and steel with an aluminized coating on it can warp at high oven temperatures. Do not bake anything near the 400° mark if your edges are more than an inch tall. Also, make sure you’re using a thermometer for accuracy since this is not a very forgiving type of pan.
  • You should never use any soap or metal utensils when hand washing jelly roll pans as it can damage the surface and cause rusting faster. Instead, use hot water and always dry fully immediately after rinsing since water spots can cause rust. You may also consider buying a nonstick coat that will be resistant to anything you throw at it.

FAQs about a Jelly Roll Pan

Are jelly roll pans interchangeable with sheet pans?

Yes, they are very similar to one another. The only difference is the shape so if you need a jelly roll pan but have a sheet pan at home then feel free to go ahead and use it. Just remember that they’re not as deep as standard-sized baking sheets and won’t hold as many baked goods (unless you’re making thinner bar cookies).

Can I convert jelly roll pans into sheet pans by adding side walls?

You can try but there’s no guarantee that it will work since some materials may warp or expand when exposed to high temperatures. This could cause your new sheet pan-jelly roll hybrid to warp and/or melt even though the oven was on the correct temperature. If you do go ahead and try it out then make sure to monitor the changes closely to avoid any accidents from taking place.

What size jelly roll pan should I buy?

Choose a pan that is one foot long (12 inches) at most and around eight inches deep; any bigger than that and they won’t fit in your oven. It should only be about 10 inches wide at most or 12 if you want larger bar cookies or thinner brownies. This way, your baked goods will have enough room to expand without overflowing into each other, which can result in uneven cooking since one side would get more heat than the other side for an extended period of time.

Is electric jelly roll pans better than gas?

From a financial standpoint, electric ones are definitely cheaper to run in the long term since you won’t have to pay for gas. However, they are not as responsive when it comes to controlling the oven’s temperature so your baked goods may come out slightly lighter or darker than planned depending on how accurate your measurements were. It can take longer to preheat an electric jelly roll pan too so be sure to set the timer earlier if that kind of oven is what you have at home.

Should I line my jelly roll pan with foil before adding batter?

It depends on whether or not you want your batch of cookies/bars etcetera, to come out with deep sides, thin sides, rustic-looking edges, etc. You can choose to line it with foil or not and then flip it over once your dough is in (this way you will be able to lift it easily and take off the foil) but if you want deep sides then no need to do that. Just fill it up until it’s about 2/3 full, then pour in your batter. If this is what you’re going for then just butter the inside of your pan instead before adding the baking sheet since you won’t have any other ingredients sticking or falling apart on you.

How should I care for my jelly roll pan?

Never put a jelly roll pan in the dishwasher because even if it says “dishwasher safe” in its description, the hot water and high temperature inside the machine will warp it out of shape. Instead, wash by hand with warm water and never use dish soap. When you’re done washing it, dry it thoroughly immediately so that no spots are left behind since they could lead to rusting/pitting over time. If your pan does start rusting even though you’ve been following these rules then just sand the surface with fine-grit sandpaper before continuing to use it because prolonged exposure to water can cause more rusting in some cases.

Conclusion for the Best Jelly Roll Pan

The best jelly roll pan is one that has a nonstick surface, can be used for baking or roasting (especially meats), and that it’s made of the most durable material. The nonstick surface makes it easier to clean since you don’t have to use as much elbow grease when scrubbing away baked-on foodstuff. Second, if you’re planning on using it for meats then make sure to get stainless steel because carbon steel can rust over time (which isn’t good if your goal was keeping your pans around for a long time). And lastly, always go with anodized aluminum. It’s lightweight yet durable even though its appearance may resemble other types of metal like cast iron.

The 12 best jelly roll pans are all made from heavy-gauge, durable materials that will last you for years to come. Each pan is designed with a nonstick finish so your creations can easily pop out of the pan when they’re done cooking without sticking or breaking. Whether looking for an affordable option or one of high quality, we have something here for every baking need. Click on any product image below to buy now and get started making delicious desserts right away.

Leave a Comment